Big Tier 1 sales, what counts: options for RedBird
Nov 19, 2026
We recommend a short checklist that your auction side signs off: a Tier 1 sale gets a live close when at least one of four things is true and your auction side says yes. Everything else closes timed. The call stays case by case, as you asked, with the same four questions every time.
The decision
We agreed on 18 Nov that the first big Tier 1 sale ends in a live online close, on a date you name, and that everyday sales stay timed. The open question: what makes a sale big enough for a live close?
A · A checklist. A live close when at least one of four things is true: a hero lot that carries press on its own; a total estimate above a level you set; a studio or franchise moment; enough approved Tier 1 bidders.
B · Case by case. Each sale decided on its own, with no set questions.
What you told us
On 18 Nov:
On the format: "Yeah, I think, I think that's right."
On what counts: "I think it's a case-by-case basis."
On studios: for launches that "may not be ... as high ticket items dollar-wise", "our studio partners might want to say, we want a big marketing, you know, bang around this"; and it "will depend somewhat on what studios want".
On the first sales: you will go through "200,000 plus items", and "maybe we do a Star Trek ... a Star Trek auction".
How others do it
Only Goldin publishes a value line for its premium sale. Heritage and Sotheby's publish sale types, not how a sale is placed in them, so in practice it is the specialist's call. Among studio sales, franchise events with press-carrying hero lots ran live, and a volume sale with a $25,000 top lot ran online.
| House or sale | What decides the format |
|---|---|
| Goldin | A published value line: the Elite sale takes lots estimated at $7,500+, runs 17 days with 30-minute extended bidding; Weekly takes $100+ and runs 9 days |
| Heritage | Signature sales get a printed catalogue, and "after Internet bidding closes, live bidding will take place"; weekly sales stay online. No placement criteria published. Its highest-value single lots (luxury real estate) run as a live session with a $100,000 deposit or proof of funds |
| Sotheby's | Premium Lots are marked ✧ and need a pre-registration application before bidding: "Some auctions and lots require additional financial verification" |
| Heritage x HBO, Game of Thrones (Oct 2024) | A studio franchise moment with press-carrying hero lots (the Iron Throne sold for $1,490,000). Run live over three sessions; 4,500+ bidders, most new to Heritage; $21,115,718 per Heritage's release |
| Julien's, The Ultimate Batmobile Auction | A single-franchise hero sale, 96 lots, run live on 23 Nov 2026 |
| Christie's x CBS Paramount, Star Trek, 2006 (press: InternetNews, Slice of SciFi) | Sold straight from the CBS Paramount archive: 1,000 lots in a three-day live sale with room, phone and real-time online bidding; $7.1M |
| HBO at Heritage, Succession, Jan 2024 (press) | Same studio as Game of Thrones, lower value (top lot $25,000): run online, 236 lots |
The Star Trek and Succession rows come from press, as we could not open the houses' own pages for those sales.
Options compared
A keeps your case-by-case call and adds four set questions to it, so studios, marketing and bidders can plan ahead.
| A · Checklist your auction side signs off (recommended) | B · Case by case | |
|---|---|---|
| Studios and marketing | Know early which sales get a live close, and can plan around it | Learn sale by sale |
| Bidder readiness | Tier 1 approvals can start as soon as a sale qualifies | Approvals start once the call is made |
| Consistency | The same four questions every time | Depends on who decides and when |
| Flexibility | The final call stays with your auction side | Full flexibility |
| Risk | Too many live closes if the list is read loosely; the sign-off and our reporting guard against it | Harder to plan marketing, approvals and studio commitments in advance |
Our recommendation and why
We recommend A, as a checklist your auction side signs off. A Tier 1 sale gets a live close when at least one of these is true, and your auction side says yes:
A hero lot that carries press on its own.
A total estimate above a level you set.
A studio or franchise moment the studio wants to mark.
Enough approved Tier 1 bidders by the close date, counting those who have saved or pre-bid lots in the sale.
Everything else closes timed.
Why:
The four points are what drove live sales elsewhere. Game of Thrones, Star Trek 2006 and the Batmobile sale were franchise moments with press-carrying heroes, and ran live. Succession, with a top lot of $25,000, ran online. Goldin's published floor shows that a value line can be set in advance.
It covers your studio point. A studio that wants "a big marketing ... bang" around lower-value items qualifies under point 3.
Point 4 is our own readiness check. No house publishes it, but a live close with few approved bidders looks empty.
It keeps case by case. The list frames the call; your auction side still makes it.
We suggest you name the estimate level for point 2. Goldin's $7,500 is the floor for its premium Elite sale, which closes timed, not a live-close threshold, so it is an example that a line can be published, not a model for yours.
What your auction side may push back on, and our answer:
"A live close costs more and a timed close can do the same." True: long extended bidding (Goldin 30 minutes for Elite, Heritage up to 30 minutes by category) also brings last-minute competition. That is why the sign-off stays with your auction side, and why we compare live and timed results after every sale.
"Criteria are bureaucratic for a specialist's decision." It is four questions, and the final call is yours.
"Bidder numbers are hard to know before the close." We show the count of approved Tier 1 bidders who saved or pre-bid lots in the sale.
What we take on and what we need from you
Povio takes on:
A "live close" setting on every Tier 1 sale, with the four questions on the sale form and your auction side's sign-off recorded.
The count of approved Tier 1 bidders shown per sale, including those who saved or pre-bid lots.
A live-versus-timed results report after every sale.
We need from you:
The estimate level for point 2.
The studio and franchise moments in your calendar, as you learn them.
The final call on each sale.
How we'll measure it
We report these after every sale, comparing live-close and timed sales:
Prices against estimate.
Bidders per lot and sell-through.
Press mentions per sale.
New Tier 1 approvals gained per live-close sale.
Sources
Goldin, About, read 19 Nov 2026
Heritage, Auction types, read 19 Nov 2026
Sotheby's, Guide for Buyers (updated 6 Nov 2026), read 19 Nov 2026
Heritage, Game of Thrones results release (13 Oct 2024), read 19 Nov 2026
Heritage, Game of Thrones sale page, auction 7366, read 19 Nov 2026
Julien's, The Ultimate Batmobile Auction, read 17 Nov 2026
Press, no house page available: InternetNews on Christie's Star Trek sale (6 Oct 2006), read 19 Nov 2026, and Slice of SciFi (8 Oct 2006), read 17 Nov 2026
Press, no house page opened: NBC New York (AP) on the Succession sale, read 17 Nov 2026